December is supposedly the “holiday” month of gift-giving, but recent experience as a track chair for the 2012 Academy of International Business (“AIB”) annual meeting tells me that the real gift-giving time, at least professionally, is from mid-January to mid-February. It was during those weeks that so many of my AIB peers gave their time and attention to read and review more than 150 papers submitted to my track for competitive or interactive presentation at this summer’s annual meeting in Washington, DC. My goal was to get multiple reviews for every submission and get them in about four weeks. Virtually every AIB member submitting a paper got a paper. Several got more than one paper to review. More than a few got several papers from me, from other AIB track chairs, and from our counterparts over at the Academy of Management. Four weeks later, practically everyone had submitted their reviews, whether it was just one or several from those “overfished” reviewers. It was amazing to observe. And it’s critically important to preserve and nurture. So that’s my topic for the month: peer review and its importance in our professional lives; peer review and the motivations of peer reviewers; and how we might do a little less “overfishing” of some especially good and generous peer reviewers. Continue reading “Peer Reviewing”
Blog No. 2012-01 (January 1, 2012)
Another Year and Another Hemisphere of Professional Life
Welcome to a new year, new semester and a new posting from The Ethicist. When writing last October, I promised to explore ethical issues in the very broad sphere of professional life, the part of our work neither falling neatly into research nor teaching. It’s the sphere of “everything else” that can be divided into hemispheres related to issues arising from membership in professional organizations like the Academy of Management and issues arising from membership in academic or research institutions. Last October, I wrote about an ethical issue arising from our work in professional organizations. This time, I thought I would travel to the other hemisphere and discuss an ethical issue more commonly (for me) encountered in academic departments, colleges and universities. The topic is service and the issue is knowing when to say no.